Although it might not feel like it, your wedding day is the first of many celebrations on your journey together as a couple. It’s the one day you’ll remember for years to come, with a new reverence for the love you share as the years go by.

When it comes to anniversaries, it can feel like you want to start off with a bang. That’s commendable, but here I think it’s important to think about longevity. You want to be able to continually outdo yourself, or at the very least stay consistent with your gifting.

All that said, it can be overwhelming to decide on a gift that shows your love and appreciation without going overboard—love is an intense emotion, after all!

Over the years, many wedding and marriage traditions have evolved to reflect cultural changes and expectations. But there’s one that has stayed just about the same—and that’s anniversary gifts. For the first few “big” anniversaries (we’re talking 1, 5, and 10 years), I say stick with the traditional materials, but put a twist on them if you’re inclined.

Below, we’ve compiled our favorite paper, wood, and aluminum-inspired gifts at a variety of price points, plus a few splurge items in each category in case you just can’t help yourself.

Year One: Paper

$17.99—Cookbook

When Ashley and her husband, Gabe, had children, they found it harder to set aside time for themselves to nurture their relationship. So, she wrote a cookbook full of recipes they could cook together and enjoy from the comfort of home. If you’re a cooking couple, this is the perfect 1-year anniversary gift!

$25—Coffee Table Book

Think you know everything about your spouse? Challenge your understanding of one another and take a deep dive into astrology as you celebrate your 1-year anniversary. This extensive coffee table book is pretty enough to leave out in your shared home, and interesting enough to keep you turning the pages for years to come.

$28—Travel Book

If your honeymoon was just one adventure on your long bucket list, there’s no question that you should celebrate your 1-year anniversary exploring together—or at least planning to! This National Parks Guide covers every park across the U.S., with travel tips, open times, and a journal to keep track of your sightseeing.

$35—Personalized Artwork

I won’t lie, I have always been a sucker for these night sky prints. They are such a unique way to celebrate a special day, reminding us of how lucky we are to spend those moments with one another. Enter the celebratory date, location, your name and your spouse’s name and receive a one-of-a-kind poster to display in your home.

$59—Photo Book

Personally, this was the gift I landed on for my husband on our first anniversary this year. It was so fun finding all the photos from our first year of marriage and arranging them in fun ways on the pages. Artifact Uprising’s page layouts even let you write short messages or long letters amid your memories, so you can include every special thought between the two covers.

$100—New York Times Commemorative Book

There are some couples that can’t get enough of the newspaper. Maybe it’s the crosswords for one, the business section for the other—and, of course, who can resist the wedding announcements? If that describes your marriage, consider gifting this New York Times Special Day book that prints the entire day’s newsprint from your wedding day. How cool is that?

Year Five: Wood

$25—Photo Print

You can never go wrong gifting a photo. After five years of marriage, there’s no doubt you and your spouse have created a ton of memories to look back on, so why not find a favorite photo to commemorate it? This custom piece lets you print any photo on a real wood pallet, keeping the 5-year anniversary tradition—with a twist!

$32—Portable Log Fire

Who says you need a fireplace to have a fire? This set of 2 or 3 kiln dried logs will keep you toasty warm on the beach, in the backyard, while you’re camping, or anywhere else you happen to be. Each log burns for 2 hours, giving you plenty of time to cozy up together and reminisce on five happy years of marriage.

$42—Wine Rack

Couples who drink wine together stay together. At least, that’s my take on the matter. This simple yet statement-making wine rack is the perfect way to show your spouse some extra love on your 5-year anniversary. If you really want to go above and beyond, you could always grab a bottle (or twelve) and fill it up!

$68—Gardening Kit

Just like a good marriage, a beautiful garden starts with passion. But, much like marriage, the payoff comes with hard work. If you’re married to someone with a green thumb, cultivate their interests with this all-in-one upgrade for your 5-year anniversary. The kit comes with five wood-handled gardening tools, a canvas seat, and a tote to pack everything up.

$90—Artisanal Candles

Scents are a powerful thing. They can transport us to nearly any time, anywhere. This thoughtful gift box comes complete with a handmade candle boasting the woodsy, cozy scents of Vermont, plus old-fashioned matches and a striker to complete the experience.

$118—Coffee Maker

If you’re celebrating five years of marriage, there’s a good chance your coffee maker is celebrating with you. Let it transition into your “something old” and give your spouse the gift of a well-made cup of joe. This gorgeous pour-over drip coffee maker isn’t just nice to look at, it’s also one of the top-rated coffee makers out there.

Year Ten: Tin or Aluminum

$39—Ring Holder

Even on your tenth wedding anniversary, your rings remain a symbol of the commitment you and your spouse have made to one another. This simple, yet elegant ring holder makes a perfect aluminum anniversary gift, and ensures that there’s always a place to safeguard that little circle that means forever.

$77—Picnic Set

Who needs a fancy restaurant when you have each other as company? By your 10-year anniversary, there’s no doubt you’ve found plenty of ways to have fun together. Your spouse will love this insulated picnic basket filled with plates, flatware, wine glasses, and napkins—it’s ready for any celebration!

$200—Pizza Oven

After 10 years of marriage, you deserve to celebrate. Go big and gift your spouse with their very own pizza oven! This outdoor oven pops right onto your charcoal grill so you can make wood-fired pizzas from the comfort of your home. It even comes with a pizza stone and peel so every pie is as perfect as your marriage.

$300—Wireless Headphones

It’s a great time in history to come up on your 10-year wedding anniversary—because there’s aluminum in nearly all the technology we use on a daily basis. These Bang & Olufsen headphones are somehow both beautiful and functional, delivering up to 5 hours of nonstop audio for your music- or podcast- loving spouse.

$315—Espresso Machine

As a caffeine-lover, nothing says romance more than a hot cup of coffee coming for me in my husband’s hands. However, that’s probably because we don’t have an espresso machine. Your 10-year anniversary is a great excuse to get your spouse this compact Nespresso Espresso Machine. Who wouldn’t love it?

$350—Bar Accessories

Celebrate your 10-year anniversary by recreating your favorite night—at home! Whip up your wedding cocktail, a drink you’ve fallen in love with over the years, or shake up something brand new. No matter what you decide, make sure to grab this gorgeous, wood-encased home bar set that leaves nothing to be desired—except for each other.

Find Inspiration

I hope this guide has inspired you to stick with tradition, at least a little, for your anniversary celebrations. The most important things to remember are to stick with your budget and give every gift with love—you can never go wrong with those two little tips. Be sure to check out the Give It blog for any more gift giving tips you might need!

Featured Image via @inspiredbythis , photo by @chels_diaz & @steezdiaz